Series Four Volume 7

Curators of Vipassanā: Romantic and Reparative Orientalism in an American Insight Group

In this paper I demonstrate how West Coast Vipassana, a mostly convert group that is part of the larger American Vipassana or Insight movement, made use of Orientalism in the early years of its development, from the mid-1970s to the end of the 1990s, to establish the group’s religious authority. While they did not invent Orientalist stereotypes, they nevertheless recycled a version of Buddhism that was designed for Western consumption long before they were born. I suggest that two forms of Orientalism shaped the construction of the group’s religious identity and authority. Looking at materials during this period of organization and institutionalization, I find that Romantic Orientalism was used to legitimize the movement and establish authority through tropes of the ancient, exotic, and mystical Orient. Continuity to Asia via the “Oriental Monk” icon theorized by Jane Iwamura lent legitimacy to Vipassana teachers, who highlighted the ancient nature of the meditation style they taught and their connection to perennial Asian wisdom. To help justify breaks with Asian Buddhist teachings and organizations, which threatened to undermine the perceived authority of the group, what I call “reparative” Orientalism painted a picture of Asian Buddhism in need of intervention, having degraded from original or early Buddhism to “traditional” Asian Buddhism. This study demonstrates the value of postcolonial analysis exemplified by the foundational work Curators of the Buddha: The Study of Buddhism Under Colonialism (Donald S. Lopez, Jr., ed., University of Chicago Press, 1995) to studies of contemporary Buddhism.

Read the article.

Tagged , , , , ,