Series Four Volume 7

Ambivalence, Critical Agency, and the Upside of Melancholia: Revisiting Curators of the Buddha

This paper picks up on two repeating motifs in Curators of the Buddha: The Study of Buddhism Under Colonialism (1995), ambivalence and melancholy, and follows them into postcolonial psychoanalytic theory in order to revisit the question of Orientalism in Buddhist studies and what decolonization can mean. Ambivalence is taken up in Homi Bhabha’s The Location of Culture (1994) with psychoanalytic theory, namely from Jacques Lacan, but Bhabha’s solution for Orientalism using mimicry has received critique for reinscribing the same power dynamics it seeks to uproot; so, I turn to ambivalence in the works of Melanie Klein, who connects the concept to melancholy in her object relations theory. Klein’s account of navigating through melancholy passes through a racialized Other, but her theory also offers a way to think through the encounter with the Other in ethical terms. I take this ethical turn on Klein by returning to Sigmund Freud’s account of critical agency in melancholia. I develop from there an account of what I describe as a melancholic ethics for decolonizing Buddhist studies psychically. This involves the work of melancholia, to use Ranjana Khanna’s term. I conclude by applying this framework back to the subjects of two chapters in Curators, Carl Jung and Giuseppe Tucci. Because there is no escaping ambivalence, melancholic ethics offers a way to live in the shadow cast by Orientalism: with critical self-reflection that paves the way for intersubjectivity.

Read the article.

Tagged , , , ,